POSLOVNI KONSULTANT – BROJ 142 / JANUAR 2025

Business Consultant – Issue 142 / January 2025

Scientific and professional journal in the fields of economics, finance, accounting, taxation, management, and applied business law.

Impressum

Publisher:
Educational and Consulting House “FINconsult” Tuzla, BiH
Publisher’s address:
Armije RBiH 15, 75000 Tuzla
tel/fax: (035) 277-275 · mobile: 061/963-917
e-mail: finconsult@bih.net.ba
Editor-in-Chief:
Prof.dr.sc. Ismet Kalić, Director of “FINconsult” Tuzla

Editorial Board:

  • Emeritus Prof.dr. Adil Kurtić, FINRA University Tuzla
  • Prof. dr. Bahrija Umihanić, Faculty of Economics Tuzla, BiH
  • Prof. dr. Senada Kurtanović, Faculty of Economics Bihać, BiH
  • Prof. dr. Helena Blažić, Faculty of Economics Rijeka, Croatia
  • Prof. dr. Jasmina Gržinić, Faculty of Economics Pula, Croatia
  • Prof.dr.sc. Marijana Šećibović, College of Tourism and Management BiH
  • Prof.dr.sc. Edin Glogić, FINRA University Tuzla

Print: “Mikroštampa” d.o.o. Tuzla
ISSN: 1986-5538

Table of Contents

  1. Changing the Paradigm of “Shareholder Value” Prof.dr.sc. Džafer Alibegović · pp. 6–12
  2. Accounting Challenges and Opportunities in Integrating ESG Criteria into the Circular Economy: A Path Toward a Sustainable Future Prof.dr.sc. Edin Glogić, Prof.dr.sc. Slavko Rakočević, Mr.sc. Ismet Đuzelić · pp. 13–27
  3. Status and Perspectives of Public Enterprises Reporting in FBiH Dr.sc. Vildana Altumbabić · pp. 28–36
  4. Research on the Impact of Direct Tax Collection on the Shadow Economy in Bosnia and Herzegovina Dr. Elmir Ramić · pp. 37–53
  5. Chatbot in Marketing Mr.sc. Ivan Kunac · pp. 54–59
  6. Strategic Role of Information Systems in Organizations in Bosnia and Herzegovina Mr. Vernes Vinčević · pp. 60–73
  7. Refund of Funds in the Indirect Taxation System in Bosnia and Herzegovina Dr. Milica Vidović · pp. 74–96
  8. Minimum Wage in FBiH for 2025 Almira Hurić, dipl.ecc. · pp. 97–101
  9. Contribution Bases for Specific Taxpayers in FBiH for 2025 Almira Hurić, dipl.ecc. · pp. 102–108
  10. Specifics in Salary Calculation in Brčko District BiH in Relation to Minimum Wage Changes in the Entities as of January 1, 2025 Mr.sc. Asmir Mujanović · pp. 109–113
  11. Sentences of Court Practice Dr.sc. Faruk Latifović · pp. 114–118
  12. Questions and Answers (Direct and Indirect Taxes, Labour Relations, and Finance) pp. 119–128
  13. Statistical Data and Work Support Service pp. 129–147
  14. Overview of New Regulations (BiH, FBiH, RS, Brčko District BiH) pp. 148–150

Articles with Abstracts

Article Abstract

1) Changing the Paradigm of “Shareholder Value”

pp. 6–12

Author: Prof.dr.sc. Džafer Alibegović, Faculty of Economics Sarajevo

This paper examines the evolution and criticism of the theory focused on maximizing shareholder wealth as the primary purpose of corporate operations. Traditionally, this theory, developed by economic theorists such as Adam Smith, Milton Friedman, Jensen and Meckling, and Eugene Fama, emphasizes the creation of shareholder value through corporate governance and market efficiency. However, critics of this paradigm, such as Freeman and scholars researching corporate social responsibility (CSR), argue that this approach neglects the interests of other stakeholders, including employees, communities, and the environment, which may lead to long-term economic and social issues. Presenting a critical assessment of the role of capital markets in determining the cost of capital, evaluating investment projects, and overall corporate governance, we conclude that companies should align their business strategies toward balancing the interests of all stakeholders—not only shareholders— to ensure sustainability and responsible long-term operations.

Reviewed as a review article

KEYWORDS: shareholder theory, CSR, cost of capital, CAPM, capital market

JEL: G17, G32

Article Abstract

2) Accounting Challenges and Opportunities in Integrating ESG Criteria into the Circular Economy: A Path Toward a Sustainable Future

pp. 13–27

Authors: Prof.dr.sc. Edin Glogić (FINRA University Tuzla), Prof.dr.sc. Slavko Rakočević (Mediterranean University Podgorica), Mr.sc. Ismet Đuzelić (Municipality of Cazin)

This paper explores accounting challenges and opportunities associated with integrating ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) criteria into the circular economy. In the context of growing global focus on sustainability, accounting practices must evolve to adequately support the goals of the circular economy and ensure transparent and accurate reporting of ESG performance. The paper analyzes current challenges accountants face when integrating ESG criteria, including inconsistent standards, lack of clear measurement and reporting guidelines, and the complexity of tracking long-term effects of sustainable practices. At the same time, it explores opportunities arising from this integration, such as improved corporate reputation, better risk management, and increased attractiveness for sustainability-oriented investors. The paper also discusses how new technologies and digitalization can facilitate the collection, analysis, and reporting of ESG data, enabling more precise tracking of sustainable business activities. Through the analysis of existing practices, the paper provides guidance for the accounting profession on how to more effectively meet the challenges and capitalize on the opportunities offered by integrating ESG criteria into the circular economy.

Reviewed as a review article

KEYWORDS: accounting, ESG, circular economy, sustainable development, reporting

JEL: M41, P56, O14

Article Abstract

3) Status and Perspectives of Public Enterprises Reporting in FBiH

pp. 28–36

Author: Dr.sc. Vildana Altumbabić, FINRA University Tuzla

Financial statement data and information are of great importance to all users, primarily investors and owners when evaluating business performance and making decisions about investing and allocation of funds. The relevance and reliability of this information are essential for user trust; therefore, it is necessary to ensure compliance. Significant deviations from the generally accepted financial reporting framework result in information presented in financial statements that is neither relevant nor reliable. The issue of reliability and relevance is particularly important for public enterprises. Public enterprises play a major role in a country’s economy and serve as one of the mechanisms through which economic functions are realized. Poor management and oversight can have multiple negative consequences for the economy. Financial reporting should also provide significant information regarding sustainable development management and climate change. The perspective of public enterprises reporting is related to the application of new sustainability reporting standards. The subject of this paper is public enterprises reporting in FBiH, the current state, and future development perspectives. The aim of the paper is to determine the existence of deviations from the applicable financial reporting framework based on the analysis of audit reports within the selected observation period and to describe development perspectives. The paper consists of three parts: the first presents an overview of public enterprise management in FBiH; the second describes the regulatory framework; and the third analyzes the current state of financial reporting based on deviations and perspectives for further development.

Reviewed as a review article

KEYWORDS: financial reporting, non-financial reporting, public enterprises, relevance and reliability of financial information

JEL: M49

Article Abstract

4) Research on the Impact of Direct Tax Collection on the Shadow Economy in Bosnia and Herzegovina

pp. 37–53

Author: Dr. Elmir Ramić, Federal Administration for Inspection Affairs Sarajevo

The shadow economy, in the broad sense, refers to conducting economic activities outside relevant legal norms (informal economy) or contrary to legal regulations (illegal economy). The shadow economy undermines the very essence of trust and loyalty between the state and its citizens, including businesses. In most cases, citizens justify participation in the shadow economy due to a lack of understanding of the harmful consequences it produces for their quality of life, nor do they recognize the illegitimate benefits participants gain. This paper investigates the impact of direct tax collection on the shadow economy in Bosnia and Herzegovina based on relevant literature, statistical data, practical examples, and statistical methods. The aim is to highlight the need for greater state engagement in reducing the shadow economy and protecting the public interest.

Reviewed as a review article

KEYWORDS: shadow economy, direct taxes, statistical methods

JEL: H25, E26

Article Abstract

5) Chatbot in Marketing

pp. 54–59

Author: Mr.sc. Ivan Kunac, University of Applied Sciences “Lavoslav Ružička” Vukovar

In the rapidly changing digital environment, companies increasingly adopt innovative technologies to improve communication with users. Among these technologies, chatbots have proven to be a highly effective tool in digital marketing strategies. Through the analysis of various chatbot types, this paper describes their applications and efficiency in enhancing customer engagement and optimizing marketing strategies. Chatbots offer numerous advantages, including 24/7 availability, cost reduction, personalized communication, and data collection, but also present challenges related to data security, understanding complex queries, and ensuring proper user experience. This paper discusses practical examples of chatbot implementation across industries, emphasizing their impact on customer satisfaction and business results.

Reviewed as a professional article

KEYWORDS: chatbot, marketing, e-marketing, digital marketing

JEL: M3, L86

Article Abstract

6) Strategic Role of Information Systems in Organizations in Bosnia and Herzegovina

pp. 60–73

Author: Mr. Vernes Vinčević, University “Vitez”, Faculty of Information Technologies

The paper analyzes key aspects of the role and importance of information systems in organizations and companies in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Information systems are viewed as fundamental resources for data and information management, business process automation, decision-making support, and improving internal and external communication. Based on an empirical study conducted across a sample of 81 companies in BiH, the paper examines the frequency of information system use, perceived benefits, impact on efficiency, productivity, and competitiveness, as well as obstacles to their full integration. The findings demonstrate that well-designed and implemented information systems contribute to service quality improvement, faster information exchange, greater transparency, and business flexibility. At the same time, challenges are identified related to insufficient investments, lack of skilled personnel, and the need to adapt organizational culture to digital transformation.

Reviewed as a review article

KEYWORDS: information systems, usage, analysis of information systems in BiH, importance of information systems

JEL: L86

Article Abstract

7) Refund of Funds in the Indirect Taxation System in Bosnia and Herzegovina

pp. 74–96

Author: Dr. Milica Vidović, Indirect Taxation Authority BiH, Tax Sector

The paper analyzes and examines important aspects of the use and significance of information systems in organizations and companies in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Information systems play a key role in all aspects of business, from data management to process automation, communication, and decision-making support. Information systems play a strategic role in business operations. Research on the use of information systems in BiH companies can be highly valuable for improving service quality, increasing efficiency, productivity, competitiveness, decision-making quality, and data analysis for business improvement, including the implementation of new information systems. The aim of this paper is to analyze, explore, and determine how often information systems are used in BiH companies and to present the level of their application, benefits, and more. For this purpose, a study was conducted on 81 companies (organizations) in Bosnia and Herzegovina.

Reviewed as a professional article

KEYWORDS: VAT refund, tax credit, VAT taxpayers, foreign legal entities, foreign nationals, tax obligations

JEL: H23, H25

Other Sections

  • Minimum Wage in FBiH for 2025 Author: Almira Hurić, dipl.ecc. · pp. 97–101
  • Contribution Bases for Specific Taxpayers in FBiH for 2025 Author: Almira Hurić, dipl.ecc. · pp. 102–108
  • Specifics in Salary Calculations in Brčko District BiH in Relation to Entity Minimum Wage Changes Effective January 1, 2025 Author: Mr.sc. Asmir Mujanović · pp. 109–113
  • Sentences of Court Practice Author: Dr.sc. Faruk Latifović · pp. 114–118
  • Questions and Answers (Direct and Indirect Taxes, Labour Relations, and Finance) pp. 119–128
  • Statistical Data and Work Support Service pp. 129–147
  • Overview of New Regulations (BiH, FBiH, RS, Brčko District BiH) pp. 148–150

To access all editions of the journal “Business Consultant” and obtain an annual subscription, you can complete the registration via the official online form.